Thursday, June 12, 2014

Reflection on Sexuality and Sexual Orientation

In the article on Women’s sexuality and sexual orientation, Peplau and Garnets talk about the shift in believing that there is no normal with either heterosexual or homosexuals.  They state that homosexuality should not be categorized as a mental illness or not normal.   They specially talks about women’s sexual orientation in her article.

Peplau and Garnets say that there is little evidence that women’s sexual orientation is linked to biological factors.  They say that recent research has shown that women’s sexual orientation is linked to personal choice and social influence.  Especially they list education, religion, and acculturation as having the greatest impacts on aspects of women’s sexuality. (pg. 160). This is why some women’s sexual orientation changes over time.  This is true of bisexual, heterosexual, and homosexual women. They state that about 77% of lesbians had had one ore male sexual partners during their lifetime (pg 160). 

Peplau and Garnets also dismisses the myth that childhood experiences have a hand in shaping women’s sexual orientation. They say that research has failed to identity any links to events shaping a woman toward lesbian or bisexual.

I really like this article by Peplau and Garnets.  The point I get from there article is that love, intimacy, and environment are the important factors for women’s sexual orientation.   Women’s sexual orientation is fluid and may change over time and is influenced by society.  Within society there are many factors that determined women’s sexual orientation.

I have read Sam's post on The Biology of the Homosexual, which I feel kind of contradicts some of the things that Peplau and Garnets talk about in there article.  I will have to read Lancaster's article to see how they differ.  I am wondering if that article talks more about men's sexual orientation because Peplau and Garnets state there are differences in what shapes women's  and men's sexual orientation.

I also liked the heterosexual questionnaire.  The questionnaire really makes you reflection on sexual orientation. I do not know what caused my heterosexuality or if it will change over time.  How silly some of these questions seemed to me.  “Would you want your children to be heterosexual, knowing the problems they’d face?” “What do you think caused your heterosexuality?”  These questions are often asks to lesbians and gays and I have gained a better insight into how unfair and meaningless these questions really are.


Reading 16: Peplau, Linda D., Garnets, Linda D – A New Paradigm for Understanding Women’s Sexuality and Sexual Orientation

Reading 17: Rochlin, Martin – The Heterosexual Questionnaire

Wednesday, June 11, 2014

Reflection on What is Social Class

I think that many people’s definition of social class relates to a person’s economic status.   Even though there has been variations of the categories of social class, three main labels stick out.  The rich, the poor, and the middle class.   Within each of the three there is a quite a bit of variation in the status of the people labeled in those groups. According to Zweig’s article on “What’s Class Got to Do with it?” social class is really a question of economic and political power (pg. 130).  He also states that this power would not exist if there were not specific classes.  He then goes into how all the classes are interrelated and dependent of each other.  He thinks that we need to view social class in terms of power not wealth and in doing this we will have a better understanding of the relationship and links between the classes.  (This does seem clear, however it just changes the naming of the label)

I found this article a little confusing.  Zweig’s states at the beginning of his article that social class is invisible, but I am not sure if I agree with that.  I think just as society will view whether a person is a male or female, light skinned or dark skinned, they can view is a person is rich, poor, or middle class.   For example, you see pro athletes or famous people, the cars they drive, their homes.  You can see they have money, especially when you see on the news how much their new homes is worth or how much they get paid.  You also see people who are living on the streets, in cars, or in homeless shelters.    All the other people you just assume and label as middle class.  I know that there is much more to this than what I am writing, but my point is that I do think that we see social class.  This is not to say that you could be wrong about what social class you label someone in.  For example the homeless person living on the street is actually a millionaire, this kind of mistake is made all the time.  We label and view people on what we see, not what we know.  This is the same with race and gender.

The Economist points out that most people stay within the social class that they were born into.  I think this is because there is a broad range of variation and movement in each class.    The Economist points out that the last 30 years has been a profitable time for the rich.    This is due in part to globalization, which I think in turn is one of the reason why people in the middle and poor class have stayed the same.

I think there will always be a social class.  It is how students are label within these classes that society needs to change their views on.   As teacher we need to be conscious that students are not tracked based on their social status.  

Reading 12: Zweig, Michael – What’s Class Got to Do With It?

Reading 13: The Economist – More or Less Equal?

Monday, June 9, 2014

Reflection on a perceptive from the other side


In Wimsatt’s article “In Defense of Rich Kids”, he says that not all white rich people are the same. This is true of all people.  He makes a good point that we need to realize we are categorizing all rich people to be the same.  He writes about how he feels he is dismissed and I would say discriminated against, because he is a white rich person.  I think that it is important for us to look at diversity issues from multiple perceptive.   As Wimsatt states he has money and he gives it away to fund social change.  He says “I know how to change history and I know it takes money” (pg 508).  He said that it takes billions of people from all backgrounds to come up with strategies to save the planet.  He is not saying he is more important than poor people but that rich people are people too.  He is the one coined the phrase “Cool Rich Kids”.   His message is not to forget about rich people and think they are all the same.  They can be part of the solution and they can change things.  You sometimes need to have capital to make changing and he is working to get more rich people involved in making these changes happen.

I think his message is a good one to reflect on.   I do not think it is fair to pick on rich people, some of them did not choose to be rich.  I think there are more people than we realize like him that are contributing their money to improve the lives of others.  It is not fair to put them all in the same category.  He is doing something and as I mentioned in previous posts everything has a ripple effect and if he can influence other rich people to do the same as him then the effect is greater.

Even though Wimsatt talks about the need for money to make changes there are also other things you can to stand out against racism.   On page 513 of the book it lists a number of things that you can do, the ones I really like are; take risks, teach your children about racism, interrupt jokes, respect, and understand.  I know that it is hard sometimes to take risks but to really change society we need to take these risks.  Speak up when you see racism.  Stop jokes when you know they are going to be a racial putdown.   Teach your children about racism and encourage them to speak out about it.   I know that I am going to work on making these changes myself, it will not be easy but I understand it is the only way that we can change things.

  One of the strategies that Kivel writes that you can use when addresses issues of racism is to use the “I” statement.   In using the “I” statement you are not specifically attacking the person who is being racist but you are letting them know how you feel about it.   When you speak out about racism then you are making a difference and you may be encouraging other people to do the same.  This is the way that we can change how society addresses issues of racism and discrimination.  We all need to work together to change it, rich, poor, black, white, young, old, and we need to teach our children and students to embrace diversity.

As Sengupta states in his article, no one is innocent.  I like this statement because it is not pointing the finger at one category or singling out a group, is statement that no one is innocence.  It simply states that we all should be working together to stop racism and discrimination.  Maybe instead of pointing fingers at groups we can focus on how we can solve the problem.  Everything that we do to speak out about discrimination and racism is step toward changing history.

Reading 53 – Wimsatt, William Upski – In Defense of Rich Kids
Reading 54 – Kivel, Paul – Uprooting Racism: How White People Can Work for Racial Justice 
Reading 55 – Sengupta, Shuddhabrata – I/Me/Mine – Intersectional Identities as Negotiated Minefields

Sunday, June 8, 2014

Reflection on Promoting Change

Reading the articles in the book have left me a little frustrated with us as human being.  Some of the issues that I was reading about required society to change the way it thought and acted.  I was only one person in society, so I was feeling a little hopeless.  So I flipped through the book looking for an article that may not frustrate me so much.  Nothing caught my eye until almost the end of the book, page 502.  I would recommend everyone take a minute and read this article.  I would also recommend reading article 51 about how to influence public policy.  (if you do not already know how).  Both these articles left me realizing if I really want to, I can make a difference.  I found this quote from Robert F. Kennedy that is a good summary for article 52.

Few will have the greatness to bend history itself, but each of us can work to change a small portion of events. It is from numberless diverse acts of courage and belief that human history is shaped. Each time a man stands up for an ideal, or acts to improve the lot of others, or strikes out against injustice, he sends forth a tiny ripple of hope, and crossing each other from a million different centers of energy and daring, those ripples build a current which can sweep down the mightiest walls of oppression and resistance.” 
― 
Robert F. Kennedy

In his article Johnson explains that the challenges we face with discrimination, exclusion, privilege, etc have been around for hundreds of years.  Even though we are seeing some changing now, there is still discrimination and inequalities.  However, as Johnsons puts it “society is always in motion”, meaning it is always changing.  It does not change at the rate that the current people living in it want it to change, but it is very fluid and it is changing.  His point is that we may not see the changes we want to see in society today, but we can impact the way society views things in the future. He states that most of the shift of the attitudes of society do not change in the current setting, but the shift occurs between generations.  I think this fits very well into the idea that we should be teaching students to be global citizens.  This is a great way to change the way that future societies view diversity.   We can also change our own mindset to be one that accepts the small changes we make today will have a ripple effect. 

I feel better about moving forward in reading the articles now.  I do go back and forth about I’m damned if I do and damned if I don’t attitude.  I guess I know I could make a bigger impact if I did some of the suggestions Cogan writes about.  She says you could take an even bigger part in making changes by influencing public policies.  You can become part of advocacy groups, you could even do something at your local level.  She states the process may seem daunting to some people, but she says help is always available.  If you have questions about how to go about something, you just ask.  She makes it sound simple. Now I feel kind of bad about myself because honestly I am probably not going to start some advocacy group to promote change at any level.  I am busy living my own life and should I feel bad about that?

What I have walked away with from both of these articles is that I can change myself.  I can set an example that may provoke other people to change in their own time and way.  The things I do to help stop discrimination, promote equality, and embrace diversity will have a slow ripple effect on society.  Also for those of you reading this reflection, the things you do will also have an effect and the more of us embracing the diversity of the world, we will then widen the circle of change.

Reading 51 – Cogan, Jeanine C. – Influencing Public Policy
Reading 52 – Johnson, Allan G – What Can We Do?  Becoming Part of the Solution.

Robert F. Kennedy Quote - http://www.pbs.org/programs/rfk-in-the-land-of-apartheid/

Friday, June 6, 2014

Reflection on Identity and Ethnic Enigma

Race and ethnicity are social constructed categories.  I had never really thought much about that until this class.  My last reflections were on race and how I thought we should do away with the category.  I know understand even if we do away with one category another one will takes its place, ethnicity.   So I feel that we are always going to categorize people, but is it how those categories are viewed that we need to change.  If they are socially constructed categories with socially constructed inequalities attached to them, then the inequalities should be able to be socially reconstructed.

In Suarez-Orozco’s article on identity in a globalized world, she describes some of the ethnic challenges immigrants and second generation people face.  Many of those challenges deal with their ethnic identities and how they are constructed by society.  First Suarez-Orozco’s mentions that immigration worldwide has challenged nation’s sense of unity (pg.221).   The diversity of immigrants threaten the identity of the citizens in the areas that they settle.    However, immigrates and their children also have their identities threatened.   So how do we integrate these two groups into a society that is free of discrimination?  How can both groups keep their ethnic identities and be free of discrimination and inequalities?  Educating people to be global citizens is a big step in that direction.

 Many immigrants are leaving areas where they had strong social and cultural ties and they knew how they fit into the world. Then they move to an area where they may not be accepted and they wonder how they fit in.   Many of them lose their ethnic identities as they are assimilated into the society where they live.  Others embrace their ethnic identities and keep their strong ties to their culture.  Some of the children develop coethnic identities.  Such as calling themselves, Mexican American, African American, etc, which studies have shown that these children feel they may be at more of an advantage then saying they are from one ethnic background.

Another problem is second generation children may not be accepted by their native country, they may not feel connected to their ancestral home land or their parents.  Their sense of identity is confusing to them.  They may feel more connected to their native born country, but that may cause disappointment with their parents.  Their parents may impose an ascribed identity on them so that they do not lost track of where they come from.  This means that these children’s identities are constructed by their parents, which could leave to problems with their children understanding who they are, and embracing other people for their differences.

When reading Mcleod’s “Everyone’s Ethnic Enigma”, he talks about being ask his ethnicity by strangers and how it left him feeling.  Since he was from a mixed marriage he had more than one ethnicity.  He felt bad because people expected him to know Spanish, or how to pronounce words just because of the way he looked.

If we can remove the social inequalities that are attached to ethnic categories then people can formulate an identity that is true to themselves.

Gordon Brown talks about global ethic vs national interest in the Ted talk link below.  The message he gives in the Ted talk is about becoming global citizens.  I think the message is a good one, but the comments on the site themselves about him are negative.  His message was that we need to all come together for good of the planet.  We need to protect all humans, we need to work together on global issues such as climate change and security.  In order to do that we need to become global citizens. To become global citizens we need to embrace all citizens’ identities.

I also like what Suarez-Orozco said in her article about people and their identities.

“The ability to formulate an identity that allows for comfortable movement between worlds will be at the very heart of achieving a truly “global soul”.

Listen to the Ted talk here:

Reading 21: Suarez-Orozco, Carola - Formulating Identity in a Globalized World
Reading 23: McLeod, Jelita - Everybody’s Ethic Enigma

Ted Talk - Global Ethic vs Nation Interest

Thursday, June 5, 2014

Reflection on Whiteness and changing Color Lines

The readings I choose for this reflection left me frustrated and hopeful.  After reading Frankenberg’s “Whiteness as an “Unmarked” Cultural Category” I was frustration.  It implies because I am white, I am privileged, have power, and dominance over other groups.  I do not agree with this.  However, I understand that many people in power are white, I think just as many people are white that do not hold positions of power, privilege or dominance.  Not all white people are the same.  We are labeled and viewed the same though by society.

Then the article frustrates me more by taking about white sameness.   So first if you are white you are discriminated against because you are white.  You are in the privilege group in society.  In being perceived as all other whites, I am labeled neutral, or lacking culture.  Many people think of people of white color as the same and boring.  I have no idea what it even means to be white.  I do only know what society believes it to mean.  I do not believe we will ever get rid of labeling people but we can change the way the labels are perceived.

When I think of myself and my culture this is what I think of.  I was told that I was from a very mixed background.  My parents told me I was part Irish, part Polish, part French, and part English.  Sometimes I think they even made some of it up.  My mother told me I was part black because I got so tanned in the summer.  Both of my parents have passed on, so I cannot ask them to verify any of this.  My mom always like to favor her Irish ancestry, or at least that what she commented on the most.  I remember things such as “Oh that is your Irish side coming out”.  My dad favored his polish ancestry. 

So after reading this article I started looking around on ancestry.com and myfamily.org.  I wanted to see if I could find any records that indicated where my ancestry came from.  After I spent (or I might say wasted) an hour looking through records, I decided I did not really care.  My ancestry could be made up by my parents, but what does it matter.  It is how I see myself.  Whether I have any linkage to any of those groups is unimportant to me.  However, during my research what I found interesting is that in 1962, when I was born both my parents had to put their race on the birth certificate and my race.  White.  I was born white.  I looked at my daughter’s birth certificate and it does not list my race or my daughters.  She was therefore born raceless, which I find interesting.  Could it be a sign that we are moving away from defining someone’s race right at birth?

When reading the article by Lee and Bean I finished feeling hopeful.  There are a lot of statistics in the article about the percent of interracial marriages based on what the native ancestry was.  The statistics point to Latinos and Asians being able to blur the color lines, mostly because they are new immigrants.  They do not have the history of discrimination that has created the black/white divide.   What I found that was hopeful it that we are changing the color lines.  The number of interracial marriages has increased greatly in the United States.   This means that there is an increasing number of people who are multiracial. These racial boundaries are flexible and they can change.

What it means to any race has and still is changing and the more I read about it the more it does not make sense to me.  Asians used to be identified as black and now they are identified as white.   What does that mean, it did not change who they were.

It appears we no longer ask for race on birth certificate.  So if everyone is born raceless can they choose what race they want to belong to?

Reading 6: Frankenberg, Ruth, Whiteness as an “Unmarked” Cultural Category’

Reading 7: Lee, Jennifer & Bean, Frank D., America’s Changing Color Lines: Immigration, Race/Ethnicity, and Multiracial Identification.

Sunday, June 1, 2014

Reflection on “Race”

Race has always been associated with power, wealth, and privilege.  This association started with the conception of the ideology of “race”.  Accord to Smedley, race was a social invention that came about in the eighteen century to separate humans based on their differences.  It was deemed necessary to stop rebellions in the Colonies.  Leaders fears that poor whites, Native Americans, and African’s would rebel against the colonial government.  In order to prevent this they created this social ideology of race.  Race was based on the differences in a humans physical features, predominately skin color.  Creating a “race” allowed Europeans to create laws the provided certain rights to one race and restricted rights to another.  Most of the power, wealth, and privileges were granted to the “white” race.  This separation of human beings based on physical features became an identity known around the world as race.  This term race started separating human beings on a wide scale and has been the reason for many of the problems in our nation today.

If race is based on skin color, how can Mrs. Phipps, who skin color is white, eyes are blue, and hair is blond, be considered black?  According to Davis, Mrs. Phipps was determined to be black because she had some amount of black ancestry.  She said she was white and her physical features were considered white features.  If no one knew about Mrs. Phipps black ancestry, wouldn’t she then be labeled by society as white?   If you think about this race really doesn’t make any sense.  What is it really?  In the colonial times it came about to allow privileged people to feel ok about the way they treated other people.  You would have thought that we would have moved beyond that as a nation today.  So how come Mrs. Phipps race today was determine by some amount of black ancestry?  Why does it matter to anyone whether she considers herself white or black?  What purpose does it serve?

I have a niece whose mother is white and her father is black.  According to her physical features, society would probably label her as black.  I have never thought about her race.  By law she would need to identify herself as black since she has black ancestry.  Why couldn’t she say she was white?

In reading 3, The Evolution of Identity, in small letters at the end of the graph it states that in 2000, the Census bureau allowed Americans to select more than one race.   So my niece could now identify herself as black and white.  What if she wanted to say she was Native American too? This again makes me wonder what the purpose is of race.  I think it is time we stop asking people what their race is. 

Reading 1, Smedley, Audrey “Race” and the Construction of Human Identity
Reading 2,Davis, James F.  Who Is Black? One Nation’s Definition.
Reading 3, The Evolution of Identity